Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

What a U.S. Crypto Investor Needs to Know About CARF

US Taxpayers May Need to File Offshore Disclosures and FBARs

The Crypto-Asset Reporting Framework (CARF) is the international system that will tell the IRS about cryptocurrency Americans hold on foreign exchanges. The United States has committed to begin receiving that information in 2029.

CARF creates no new tax and no new filing requirement. It ends the assumption that activity on a foreign exchange stays out of view. If you have traded on a foreign platform, moved coins between wallets, or cannot document what you paid for what you sold, deal with it before the IRS has another government’s data in hand, not after.

What Is CARF?

CARF is an OECD standard, approved in 2022, that requires crypto exchanges and other crypto-asset service providers to identify their customers and report their transactions to the provider’s home tax authority. That authority then sends the information to each customer’s country of tax residence.

CARF reports activity, not balances. For each customer, the provider reports name, address, tax residence, and taxpayer identification number, plus annual totals for each crypto asset: cash purchases and sales, crypto-to-crypto exchanges, and transfers, including transfers out to private wallets.

That leaves a gap that matters. CARF can show the IRS that you sold $200,000 of bitcoin on a foreign exchange. It cannot show what you paid for it. Proving that is your job.

CARF is the crypto counterpart to the Common Reporting Standard, which already exchanges bank and securities account data among more than 100 countries. The United States never joined that standard and instead relies on FATCA. It has committed to join CARF.

When Does CARF Reach U.S. Investors?

What is the IRS Audit Statute of Limitations - San Diego Tax Attorney - Waive the Statute of Limitations in an IRS Audit - Tax AttorneyThe IRS is scheduled to begin receiving CARF data in 2029. Other countries start sooner:

  • 2027: 48 jurisdictions, including the United Kingdom and the EU member states, exchange data on 2026 transactions. Exchanges in those countries began collecting customer data on January 1, 2026.
  • 2028: Canada and Mexico, among others.
  • 2029: the United States and Argentina.

The U.S. date is a commitment, not yet a rule. As of November 18, 2026, the U.S. CARF regulations (RIN 1545-BQ82) remain at the proposed-rule stage. The date has already slipped once: the OECD’s June 2025 list placed the United States in the 2028 group.

Do not treat 2029 as a grace period. Your obligations for 2025, 2026, and every other year are the same today as they will be when the data arrives.

Reporting timeline · domestic 1099-DA and CARF, 2025–2029

Domestic broker reporting already applies; CARF information on U.S. taxpayers’ foreign accounts is scheduled to follow in 2029.

What Does CARF Cover?

CARF follows the service provider. Where your crypto sits determines what gets reported.

Foreign exchanges and custodial platforms.

This is CARF’s core. If a provider in a participating country holds your crypto, it identifies you as a U.S. taxpayer and reports your activity.

Self-custody wallets.

The Action Cryptocurrency Investors Need to Take ImmediatelyNo provider reports a wallet you control. But the coins got there from somewhere and will leave through somewhere. A transfer from a reporting exchange to a private wallet is itself reportable under CARF, and cashing out runs through an exchange or bank. Self-custody hides what happens in the middle, not the way in or the way out. Separately, in October 2026, FinCEN withdrew its proposal to require banks and money services businesses to report transactions involving unhosted wallets. That removes a reporting proposal; it changes nothing about the tax.

Decentralized finance.

The White House has said U.S. CARF rules should not impose new reporting on DeFi transactions. The final rules will settle how far that goes. Whether a protocol is decentralized doesn’t affect whether your gains are taxable.

What Does the IRS Already Receive?

For most U.S. investors, the reporting that matters right now is domestic. U.S. crypto brokers report customer sales to the IRS on Form 1099-DA under final regulations issued in August 2024.

  • 2025 sales: gross proceeds required; cost basis optional (IRS Form 1099-DA instructions).
  • 2026 sales and later: basis also required, but only for “covered” assets, meaning those bought on or after January 1, 2026 and held in the same broker account until sold (IRS instructions).

That creates a predictable problem. Say you sold bitcoin in 2025 for $40,000 that you bought for $32,000. Your Form 1099-DA shows $40,000 and no basis, so the IRS’s matching system sees $40,000 of proceeds. Your return must show the $32,000 cost, and you must be able to prove it. If you cannot document basis, the IRS can treat it as zero and tax the full $40,000.

The problem does not end in 2026. Crypto bought before 2026 or transferred into a broker from another wallet or exchange is not covered, and its basis will not be reported. For long-term holders, that is most of what they own.

Form 1040 also asks every filer whether they sold, received, exchanged, or otherwise disposed of a digital asset during the year. You sign that answer under penalties of perjury.

What Do You Owe and Report Today?

Federal income tax.

The IRS treats crypto as property. Selling it, swapping one coin for another, and spending it are all taxable events, and staking rewards and crypto paid for work are income. Where you hold the crypto makes no difference.

California income tax.

California taxes residents on worldwide income and has no lower rate for long-term capital gains. Crypto gains are taxed as ordinary income, at rates up to 13.3% in the top bracket. A California resident’s gain on a foreign exchange is California income.

FBAR.

Under FinCEN Notice 2020-2, a foreign account holding only crypto is not FBAR-reportable, and that notice still governs. An account that also holds cash or other reportable assets is reportable in full once your foreign accounts together exceed $10,000 at any point in the year. Most foreign exchange accounts hold a cash balance at some point. Check every one.

Form 8938.

The IRS has never said whether crypto on a foreign exchange is a “specified foreign financial asset”; the answer turns partly on whether the exchange counts as a foreign financial institution. For U.S. residents, the thresholds are $50,000 at year-end or $75,000 at any time for single filers, and $100,000 or $150,000 for joint filers. Failing to file a required Form 8938 carries a $10,000 penalty.

Our view: if crypto on a foreign custodial exchange puts you over the threshold, file. An unnecessary disclosure costs little; a missed required one does not. Practitioners widely take the same position. And keep the two forms separate in your thinking: an answer under FBAR does not settle Form 8938, or the reverse.

The Most Important Thing to Understand

Important IdeaCARF changes what the IRS can see, not what you owe. Every dollar of tax it might uncover is already owed today.

What changes is who tells the story first. Once the IRS holds another government’s report of your foreign activity, you are no longer explaining your transactions; you are answering for them.

That difference has legal consequences. The IRS Criminal Investigation Voluntary Disclosure Practice is open only to taxpayers whose noncompliance the IRS has not already learned about from a third party, including another government agency. CARF data comes from other governments. Once it reaches the IRS, that option may no longer be available.

If Prior Years Were Wrong

Not every problem is the same problem, and they are fixed differently.

  • Missing basis or calculation errors are usually a matter of rebuilding records and amending returns.
  • Unreported income or missed foreign reporting can involve penalty relief or disclosure procedures with strict eligibility rules, some of which close once the IRS makes contact.

Establish which category you are in before filing anything. The order in which you correct problems matters, and an amended return filed without a plan can narrow your options rather than fix them.

Six Things to Do Now

List every place your crypto has been. U.S. exchanges, foreign exchanges, wallets, and DeFi protocols, current and closed. Download complete transaction histories now; platforms shut down and records disappear.

Reconcile your 2025 Form 1099-DA. Match each reported sale to its purchase. Never report gross proceeds as gain.

Rebuild basis for pre-2026 and transferred crypto. Your broker will not report it. Purchase records, exchange statements, and wallet transfer histories are your proof.

Check every foreign account for cash. A cash balance, even briefly, can make the whole account FBAR-reportable.

Take a Form 8938 position and document why. If you are over the threshold, filing is the safer default.

Have prior years reviewed before the data arrives. Find out what is wrong, and which category it falls in, while the choice of how to fix it is still yours.

Accounting, Tax and Legal in One Place

Crypto reporting problems are accounting problems (reconstructing basis), tax problems (what is taxable and what must be reported), and sometimes legal problems (prior years, penalties, disclosure). If you handle them separately, fixing one can create another. Allen Barron handles all three together.

If you hold crypto on a foreign exchange, have gaps in your basis records, or aren’t sure your prior returns are right, Allen Barron offers a complimentary, substantive, and confidential consultation. We invite you to learn more about the integrated tax, legal, accounting and business consulting services of Allen Barron and use the chat module on this page, contact us, or call today to schedule a free consultation at 866-631-3470.